Petee’s Pies Company

Petee’s Pie Company, led by Petra “Petee” Paredez, was named The Absolute Best Pie in NYC by New York Magazine. Petra, inspired by her family’s baking legacy, creates sweet and savory pies using locally sourced ingredients. Petee’s offers a seasonal menu of both traditional and inventive pies, earning it a spot among NYC’s top-ranked pie shops.

From classics like NY Sour Cherry Crumb to unique creations like the Nesselrode, Petee’s Pie Co. caters to all taste buds. Beyond pies, the shop also delights customers with homemade ice cream creations. Petra’s expertise and commitment to quality have solidified Petee’s as a beloved destination for pie enthusiasts, creating the ultimate dessert experience at Gotham West Market.


Monday- Thursday: 4pm -10pm
Friday-Sunday: 11am -11pm